Take a look at our
ThinkPads.com HOME PAGE
For those who might want to contribute to the blog, start here: Editors Alley Topic
Then contact Bill with a Private Message

T60P VS MBP, now that it can run windows......

T60/T61 Series
Message
Author
pundit
Junior Member
Junior Member
Posts: 318
Joined: Tue Feb 28, 2006 9:52 pm
Location: Ann Arbor, USA
Contact:

#151 Post by pundit » Sat May 06, 2006 4:37 pm

Scratch wrote:... i can live vicariously through Pundit for the time being.
And vicariously live you shall. :)

I've started writing up some stuff on the machine, but I got bored and decided to shoot some pictures for a start instead. Here it is!

(Not a work in progress anymore.)
Happily picks up his three grand; unhappily hands it over to another company.

archer6
Moderator Emeritus
Moderator Emeritus
Posts: 2674
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 10:51 pm
Location: California, USA

#152 Post by archer6 » Mon May 08, 2006 5:52 pm

Scratch wrote:T'Pads are the closest PC to a Mac to me...meaning I feel that the customization and software enhancements give these machines a better feel and, most often, the user a better experience than the vast majority of portable systems out there.


Yes I agree, I think that the ThinkPad has made the fastest progress in regards to being close to the Mac in user experience.
Scratch wrote:I'm happy with my T60p, though I wish that Lenovo would step up quicker in dealing with the problems that these systems have.
Precisely! I have had a lot of contact lately with tech support for the three new 60 series ThinkPads I have. The experience has been very mixed. Sometimes I call and it's like the old IBM tech support, very good work from experienced people. Then other times, very poor work from obviously untrained, inexperienced people.
Scratch wrote:I'm hoping for a full recovery because I like having the option to be very satisfied with 2 very different systems that are equally effective in their respective and sometimes overlapping arenas.
A full recovery is needed from each manufacturer in my opinion as Apple has descended in the level of tech support and customer satisfaction in recent times.
Scratch wrote:I think that both systems are suffering the pains of the rush to market.

Rush to market is certainly accurate and I think that it's the primary reason that we are seeing the issues we are with both the ThinkPad & MBP. However I do feel that Lenovo is managing it better with less serious issues than the MBP.
Scratch wrote:I think an MBP is in my future when the product comes into its own and i can live vicariously through Pundit for the time being.
I am really happy that I can also live vicariously through pundit....and yes, only for the time being. :D
Favorites From My ThinkPad Collection

Workstations... T40p ~ T41p ~ T42p ~ T43p ~ T60p ~ T61p ~ W500 ~ W510
T Series..... T22 ~ 30 ~ 40 ~ 41 ~ 42 ~ 43 ~ 60 ~ 400 ~ 500 ~ 510
X Series..... X20 ~ 30 ~ 40 ~ 60 ~ 60s ~ 200 ~ 200s ~ 301
Netbooks... S-10 ~ S-12

nhidog
Posts: 11
Joined: Wed Apr 12, 2006 8:45 pm

#153 Post by nhidog » Tue May 09, 2006 2:08 am

I had a Powerbook G4 prior to the Thinkpad T60. OSX is great, stable with nice eye candy but that was until I tried out Linux and XGL. XGL does some mind blowing effects. And Linux has crashed less on me than OSX. Yes OSX does crash particularly with Firefox, I wasn't too fond of Safari due to its incompatibility with some financial sites.

Thinkpad T60 + Linux + XGL = one gorgeous machine. Takes a bit of time, but it was well worth it. Just take a look at what my desktop is capable of. Ubuntu rocks!

http://i59.photobucket.com/albums/g308/ ... enshot.png

Note: If the image is over 50KB, there should be either a warning in the title post or the image shouldn't be embedded; nice XGL demo :) -Wolf

pundit
Junior Member
Junior Member
Posts: 318
Joined: Tue Feb 28, 2006 9:52 pm
Location: Ann Arbor, USA
Contact:

#154 Post by pundit » Wed May 10, 2006 10:01 am

nhidog wrote:Thinkpad T60 + Linux + XGL = one gorgeous machine. Takes a bit of time, but it was well worth it. Just take a look at what my desktop is capable of. Ubuntu rocks!
Yes, but what of the few people who buy the Apple machine, and replace OS X with something like an XGL friendly distribution? Some people might want both a shiny exterior and a shiny interior.
Happily picks up his three grand; unhappily hands it over to another company.

archer6
Moderator Emeritus
Moderator Emeritus
Posts: 2674
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 10:51 pm
Location: California, USA

#155 Post by archer6 » Wed May 10, 2006 11:53 am

pundit wrote:
nhidog wrote:Thinkpad T60 + Linux + XGL = one gorgeous machine. Takes a bit of time, but it was well worth it. Just take a look at what my desktop is capable of. Ubuntu rocks!
Yes, but what of the few people who buy the Apple machine, and replace OS X with something like an XGL friendly distribution? Some people might want both a shiny exterior and a shiny interior.
pundit-

How do you have your MBP configured?
Favorites From My ThinkPad Collection

Workstations... T40p ~ T41p ~ T42p ~ T43p ~ T60p ~ T61p ~ W500 ~ W510
T Series..... T22 ~ 30 ~ 40 ~ 41 ~ 42 ~ 43 ~ 60 ~ 400 ~ 500 ~ 510
X Series..... X20 ~ 30 ~ 40 ~ 60 ~ 60s ~ 200 ~ 200s ~ 301
Netbooks... S-10 ~ S-12

pundit
Junior Member
Junior Member
Posts: 318
Joined: Tue Feb 28, 2006 9:52 pm
Location: Ann Arbor, USA
Contact:

#156 Post by pundit » Wed May 10, 2006 3:21 pm

archer6 wrote:
pundit wrote: Yes, but what of the few people who buy the Apple machine, and replace OS X with something like an XGL friendly distribution? Some people might want both a shiny exterior and a shiny interior.
pundit-

How do you have your MBP configured?
Is that a software or hardware question?

If it's a hardware: 2x2GHz, 2x1GB, 7200rpm 100GB.

If it's software: Currently getting friendly with Mac OS X, but if the annoying keyboard shortcuts get to me, I will move over to Fedora Core 5. Eventually I guess it will be identical to my T60p, except for the slightly slower processor.
Happily picks up his three grand; unhappily hands it over to another company.

noob_4_life
Posts: 10
Joined: Tue May 02, 2006 3:20 am
Location: bay area; california

#157 Post by noob_4_life » Thu May 11, 2006 2:39 am

While waiting for my thinkpad T60p to come and expecting that it will be delayed, i went to fry's(computer outlet) and picked up the 15.4'' macbook pro to play around with. I have 15 days to try it out and return if indeed i dont like it.

2ghz 1gig of ram is the specs..

My initial impressions...SEXY!!! omg..Screen is beautiful and the sound coming out of it is rich and actually has some bass to it. Front Row is extremely nice. This laptop is a must for anyone who loves multimedia stuff(music, videos. and such). It seems so much more like a consumer laptop instead of being a professional laptop.

This baby gets extremely hot on the bottom. There is no heat on the palm rest or anywhere else besides the bottom of the laptop. Besides that the only other thing i can complain about is the battery. With everything on and on full, it only lasted two hours. Thats the price to pay for such a sexy beast.

I hope my T60p comes before the 15 days is up. I want to compare the two.
previous laptop:
Asus Z71V-2.13ghz core solo, 2 gigs of ram,60 gb hd @7200rpm, nvidia 6600 go


current laptop:
thinkpad T60p, 2.16 ghz core duo, 2 gigs of ram, 100 gb hd @7200rpm, ati firegl v5200

astro
Junior Member
Junior Member
Posts: 370
Joined: Wed Feb 08, 2006 3:07 pm
Location: Australia

#158 Post by astro » Thu May 11, 2006 4:37 am

pundit wrote:Currently getting friendly with Mac OS X, but if the annoying keyboard shortcuts get to me, I will move over to Fedora Core 5.
I think the keyboard shortcut system is brilliant on the Mac. Highly configurable. I also personally like the position of the command key, which you hit with your thumb instead of with your pinky on a PC (all those CTRL+?? combinations).

The other thing I absolutely LOVE about the Mac is what you get when you press OPTION + [any letter]. There has never been an easier way to type characters with umlauts and accents (e.g. [gets out character map, sigh] é, õ, etc.)... In this respect, Windows is seriously in the dark ages.
60-200763-2500-2.0-1024-1400-14.1-1400-1050-3945-100-5400

pundit
Junior Member
Junior Member
Posts: 318
Joined: Tue Feb 28, 2006 9:52 pm
Location: Ann Arbor, USA
Contact:

#159 Post by pundit » Thu May 11, 2006 8:06 am

astro wrote:I also personally like the position of the command key, which you hit with your thumb instead of with your pinky on a PC (all those CTRL+?? combinations).
I can't believe I'm admitting this, but I agree with you. Though it takes me a while (my fingers move elsewhere, and I often have to double-take), I spent some time on my older machine yesterday as I was transferring some files, and my pinkie did begin to strain as I had to stretch it to the bottom left of the keyboard where my cntrl key was.

I still would like a home/end key though. Not all apps are brilliant enough to support cntrl-a/cntrl-e, and I haven't really gotten into the Applesque cmd+left/cmd+right.
Happily picks up his three grand; unhappily hands it over to another company.

archer6
Moderator Emeritus
Moderator Emeritus
Posts: 2674
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 10:51 pm
Location: California, USA

#160 Post by archer6 » Thu May 11, 2006 12:37 pm

pundit wrote:
archer6 wrote: pundit-

How do you have your MBP configured?
Is that a software or hardware question?

If it's a hardware: 2x2GHz, 2x1GB, 7200rpm 100GB.

If it's software: Currently getting friendly with Mac OS X, but if the annoying keyboard shortcuts get to me, I will move over to Fedora Core 5. Eventually I guess it will be identical to my T60p, except for the slightly slower processor.
Oops... I meant to ask about the Software Config.
Favorites From My ThinkPad Collection

Workstations... T40p ~ T41p ~ T42p ~ T43p ~ T60p ~ T61p ~ W500 ~ W510
T Series..... T22 ~ 30 ~ 40 ~ 41 ~ 42 ~ 43 ~ 60 ~ 400 ~ 500 ~ 510
X Series..... X20 ~ 30 ~ 40 ~ 60 ~ 60s ~ 200 ~ 200s ~ 301
Netbooks... S-10 ~ S-12

astro
Junior Member
Junior Member
Posts: 370
Joined: Wed Feb 08, 2006 3:07 pm
Location: Australia

#161 Post by astro » Thu May 11, 2006 5:53 pm

pundit wrote:I still would like a home/end key though. Not all apps are brilliant enough to support cntrl-a/cntrl-e, and I haven't really gotten into the Applesque cmd+left/cmd+right.
Have you tried Fn-Left, Fn-Right? I think that Fn-Up and Fn-Down are also PgUp and PgDn respectively.

You do make a good point though, in some apps Cmd-left and Cmd-right works, in others, it doesn't. Same with Opt-Left/Right (same as Ctrl-Left/Right in Windows -- moves one word at a time). It is quite annoying that these key combos are not consistent in their functionality, not because you can't do it at all (you can try one of the other combos mentioned), but because it is just inconsistent, which flies in the face of all the other great consistent functionality that OS X is all about.
60-200763-2500-2.0-1024-1400-14.1-1400-1050-3945-100-5400

Scratch
Sophomore Member
Posts: 223
Joined: Tue Apr 04, 2006 10:45 am
Location: Boston, MA

That MBP might be closer that I previously thought...

#162 Post by Scratch » Sun May 14, 2006 1:40 pm

because I'm getting sick and tired of waiting for fixes from Lenovo for annoying and widespread problems.

I'd really like this intermittent "screen won't return from Power Savings" thing to be resolved. I've been through it 3 times with 2 levels of support and have gotten nowhere.

I run several different CAD/CAE packages on this machine for work, demo and presentation purposes. When the screen blacks out when one of these programs is running and none of the "Fn + SpcBar" or "Return", etc keystrokes works to bring it back, Im forced to try to enter Standby which generates different warning popups in the various programs which I then have no sure method of responding to blind. The only reliable solution is to Force a Power Down and reboot which is rather inconvenient to say the least.

I don't think a $3k+ laptop should have these issues or should have been shipped without being thoroughly tested. It's got to be the ATI package or the Lenovo to Windows PM relationship that's causing the problem. Why the hell can't they fix it? It's been weeks.

It's also ridiculous to me to have 2 interfaces for maintaining Power Management configurations and the the 2 can't stay in synch.

Why can I make a timers change in Lenovo Power Manager that doesn't propogate to Window Control Panel Power Settings? If you install Lenovo Power Manager it should replace the MS Applet in Control Panel with it's own functionality so there's only one point of control.

At present my T60p only sticks in screen timeout when on batteries which is, unfortunately, when screen timouts are most helpful, but then it will randomly (with no known system config changes) start occuring in the AC state again and that's when I start losing data.

Anyway...I've got an MBP 17" on order to evaluate with a developer build of Leopard (I really want my FW800 port) and I'm clearing the road to send the T60p back to it's maker citing irreconcileable differences. I'll find another way around this CAD issue even if it's Boot Camp for a period of time...it can't be much worse than this ridiculous Power Management/Screen issue.

When they lose me as a supporter it only costs them ~90 machines in my organization over a year or so, but when long term customers and partners start asking why we've dumped (xIBM)Lenovo in Engineering I'm sure not going to sugar coat it and it could get more costly..There are already a lot grumblings over quality of support out there. I fear that it will get worse before it gets better.
T'Pad 600e, 770x, A20p, A21p, A30p, A31p (2653-H3U), T43p (2668-Q2U) & T60p (2623-DDU)...it's an addiction.

kwramm
Freshman Member
Posts: 70
Joined: Fri Mar 24, 2006 1:39 pm
Location: Oslo, Norway
Contact:

#163 Post by kwramm » Sun May 14, 2006 6:11 pm

astro wrote:
pundit wrote: . I also personally like the position of the command key, which you hit with your thumb instead of with your pinky on a PC (all those CTRL+?? combinations).
you can change this easily on any windows PC to be Mac compatible with a program called Sharpkeys (www.randyrants.com). I got it to make my mac usb keyboard work on xp, but you can remap whatever key you like. It's a registry thing only so you're not running anything in the background to get this functionality.

zephyr
Posts: 48
Joined: Fri May 12, 2006 2:05 am

#164 Post by zephyr » Mon May 15, 2006 3:11 am

Hi Pundit, I saw that you had owned a T60P but had returned it in favour of a Macbook Pro 15.4". I am considering something along the same lines. Some questions for you:

1. In Windows and Linux, you can alt-tab between terminal/shell windows, but in MacOS multiple terminals are considered one application, so command-tab will not cycle between them. I saw that command-tilde will cycle unidirectionally through them but will not swap the two terminals at the top of the stack. Have you gotten accustomed to this?

2. I bought a MBP from Amazon a few weeks ago, but it was outrageously hot while plugged into AC power. Do you find your MBP as hot as your T60P on either AC power or battery?

3. I see from your personal webpage that you are a hardcore LaTeX user, so you must know your way around Linux/Unix. How do you find the MacOS BSD? Is there any weirdness with respect to the Unix-ness? Can you install new source code with a simple configure/make/make install?

3.5. Is there any reason at all to run Linux via dual booting or through virtualisation software?

4. Have you tried the Parallels virtualisation software yet? Does Windows run briskly?

5. Back to LaTeX: Am I right in assuming that I can run LaTeX on MacOS? I typically use latex, dvips, and gv on Linux or Solaris (yes, I was a grad student once too).

FuguTabetai
Posts: 34
Joined: Sun Jan 29, 2006 5:50 pm
Location: Tokyo, Japan
Contact:

#165 Post by FuguTabetai » Mon May 15, 2006 4:15 am

zephyr wrote:Hi Pundit, I saw that you had owned a T60P but had returned it in favour of a Macbook Pro 15.4". I am considering something along the same lines. Some questions for you:
I'm not Pundit, but I do most of my work on a 15" PowerBook, and have a T60p at home (until linux support for it gets up to snuff.)
I thought I would throw my opinions into the mix.
zephyr wrote: 1. In Windows and Linux, you can alt-tab between terminal/shell windows, but in MacOS multiple terminals are considered one application, so command-tab will not cycle between them. I saw that command-tilde will cycle unidirectionally through them but will not swap the two terminals at the top of the stack. Have you gotten accustomed to this?

I haven't had a problem with this. I use a combination of alt-tab, alt-tilde, and exposé (mapped to the mighty mouse squeeze function.) At first I thought I would miss virtual desktops (coming from linux) so I installed "Desktop Manager", a free virtual desktop program for OSX, but with Exposé and hiding inactive applications (can still alt-tab to them though) I found I didn't need it. I miss exposé in windows a lot now. :)
zephyr wrote: 3. I see from your personal webpage that you are a hardcore LaTeX user, so you must know your way around Linux/Unix. How do you find the MacOS BSD? Is there any weirdness with respect to the Unix-ness? Can you install new source code with a simple configure/make/make install?
I'm a post-doc researcher in computer science, and Emacs and LaTeX were the first two things I put on my PowerBook. I haven't had any problem with the BSD layer, and once I set up Apple's X11 system, things went pretty smoothly. You can configure / make /make install most software, but I would suggest looking into DarwinPorts or fink, apt-get style repositories for the Mac that have taken care of most of the pain for you.
zephyr wrote: 3.5. Is there any reason at all to run Linux via dual booting or through virtualisation software?
I can't think of a reason.
zephyr wrote: 5. Back to LaTeX: Am I right in assuming that I can run LaTeX on MacOS? I typically use latex, dvips, and gv on Linux or Solaris (yes, I was a grad student once too).
There are many flavors of LaTeX available for OSX. I installed http://ii2.sourceforge.net/tex-index.html and Carbon Emacs Package http://homepage.mac.com/zenitani/emacs-e.html, which has very nice Japanese language suport and integrates with LaTeX well. I've also heard very good things about TeXshop, but rest assured there are many ways to get LaTeX running on your mac. Also check out BibDesk for a nice bibtex reference management tool.

good luck.
ThinkPad A31 2652-D4U Fedora Core 4, T60p 2007-83J windows :(, PowerBook 15" 1.67 GHz G4 OSX 10.4

pundit
Junior Member
Junior Member
Posts: 318
Joined: Tue Feb 28, 2006 9:52 pm
Location: Ann Arbor, USA
Contact:

#166 Post by pundit » Mon May 15, 2006 9:16 am

My responses are surprisingly different from Fugu, but here goes:
zephyr wrote:1. In Windows and Linux, you can alt-tab between terminal/shell windows, but in MacOS multiple terminals are considered one application, so command-tab will not cycle between them. I saw that command-tilde will cycle unidirectionally through them but will not swap the two terminals at the top of the stack. Have you gotten accustomed to this?
This isn't the behaviour just for terminals, it is the behaviour for most applications. cmd-tab cycles through the apps, and cmd-tilde cycles through windows in an app. You will begin to (or at least I find myself doing so) try to keep up (un-minimiaed) only one window of each app, so cmd-tab will behave similar to alt-tab like you'd expect.

I wouldn't say I have pleasantly gotten accustomed to this, but I've started making shifts to my working style to accomodate it. And, like Fugu said, there are things like Exposé which make things a lot easier. And it turns out that you won't be minimising or quitting all applications you aren't currently working on in OS X. That's cool.
zephyr wrote:2. I bought a MBP from Amazon a few weeks ago, but it was outrageously hot while plugged into AC power. Do you find your MBP as hot as your T60P on either AC power or battery?
It does get very very warm if the ambient temperature in the room is already warm to begin with. Right now, I'm in a cool room, and it's been on my lap for the past hour or so, and it doesn't affect me (or so I claim until it turns out I can't have kids, or something). In a warm room on the other hand, my palms will begin to sweat (and I never sweat) after a few minutes of resting on it.

My T60p was nowhere near as warm. But my T60p was nowhere near as shy of turning on its fans either.

I am looking into ways to just lower my MBP's fan turn-on temperature threshold. There is no reason for it to sit this quiet when it is getting warm. I'd rather the fans just come on earlier instead. This is not a serious change, and should be a matter of editing a text file or three.
zephyr wrote:3. I see from your personal webpage that you are a hardcore LaTeX user, so you must know your way around Linux/Unix. How do you find the MacOS BSD? Is there any weirdness with respect to the Unix-ness? Can you install new source code with a simple configure/make/make install?
And here's where I begin to differ with Fugu. Unlike you who've seen Solaris, I have never worked on (what I'm going to call old school) Unix. I've worked on GNU/Linux over a decade now and I find Unix similar enough on the surface, but too different for comfort just underneath. There are often things that I want to do and have done over numerous years I need to read up on, and this irks me. My documentation of such trials and tribulations ought to end up here, but you knew that.

It's a Unix, I suppose. But it's just that. I want a GNU/Linux, if that makes sense. There is a ton of wierdness from where I see it, and building an application is never as trivial as fetching the sources, configuring them and making them.

But, like Fugu said, you can add additional layers like DarwinPorts and Fink to provide this functionality for you. Something I feel ought not to have been broken in the first place. But, given some time, you can get all the things you want working on there.
zephyr wrote:3.5. Is there any reason at all to run Linux via dual booting or through virtualisation software?
None for virtualisation, but there is more than enough reason to dual boot Linux/remove OS X altogether. As shiny and lickable as its interface is, for one who is not used to it, it can get in the way. And more importantly, OS X's kernel is demonstrably slower than Linux for serious computing. And I mean less than half the performance in some situations. Here is a cherry picked source. [berkeley.edu]
zephyr wrote:4. Have you tried the Parallels virtualisation software yet? Does Windows run briskly?
I haven't tried because I don't have any need for or interest in this.
zephyr wrote:5. Back to LaTeX: Am I right in assuming that I can run LaTeX on MacOS? I typically use latex, dvips, and gv on Linux or Solaris (yes, I was a grad student once too).
Yes, like Fugu said there are numerous TeX distributions that work. I am not entirely certain which of those is "better" and how I would go about determining that, but I have a rebuild of TeTeX for Mac OS X and an Emacs rebuild called Aquamacs that foot the bill nicely.

-----

While I crib about performance, funny shortcuts and unnecessary shininess, I am spending this time trying to get everything I need running on Mac OS X and getting used to its idiosyncrasies. No one ever said switching OSs is going to be a trivial undertaking; even one as purportedly easy to use as OS X.
Happily picks up his three grand; unhappily hands it over to another company.

zephyr
Posts: 48
Joined: Fri May 12, 2006 2:05 am

#167 Post by zephyr » Mon May 15, 2006 3:19 pm

pundit wrote:I wouldn't say I have pleasantly gotten accustomed to this, but I've started making shifts to my working style to accomodate it. And, like Fugu said, there are things like Exposé which make things a lot easier. And it turns out that you won't be minimising or quitting all applications you aren't currently working on in OS X. That's cool.
I write a lot of software the old-fashioned way that I learned in undergrad and grad school: vi open in one terminal and gcc in another. The lack of alt-tab'ing between terminal windows is a major problem with me since I do this incessantly. Bringing up Expose and clicking on one of the windows just isn't going to do it.


I am looking into ways to just lower my MBP's fan turn-on temperature threshold. There is no reason for it to sit this quiet when it is getting warm. I'd rather the fans just come on earlier instead. This is not a serious change, and should be a matter of editing a text file or three.


There is a lot of talk about this now on the Apple discussion forums. Evidently it is more than just a matter of a text file; people have been finding that the CPU heatsink paste hasn't been properly applied.
It's a Unix, I suppose. But it's just that. I want a GNU/Linux, if that makes sense. There is a ton of wierdness from where I see it, and building an application is never as trivial as fetching the sources, configuring them and making them.
Can you give me an example of where configure/make/make install does not work for you? I assume that you would just need to provide configure with the correct directory with "--prefix=", no?

But, like Fugu said, you can add additional layers like DarwinPorts and Fink to provide this functionality for you. Something I feel ought not to have been broken in the first place. But, given some time, you can get all the things you want working on there.
Is the software from Fink/DarwinPorts the source code or binaries? Are they similar to RPMs in the Linux world?

frzntoz
Posts: 2
Joined: Mon May 01, 2006 1:42 pm
Location: Alberta, Canada

#168 Post by frzntoz » Mon May 15, 2006 3:27 pm

zephyr wrote: I write a lot of software the old-fashioned way that I learned in undergrad and grad school: vi open in one terminal and gcc in another. The lack of alt-tab'ing between terminal windows is a major problem with me since I do this incessantly. Bringing up Expose and clicking on one of the windows just isn't going to do it.
Actually, you can cycle through those windows with apple key-tilde key.
This makes life much easier as I write code in the same manner :).

Sadly, I'm on my second macbook pro & its too hot so I am returning it... which is very annoying as I'm trying to get my research done for my thesis. sigh. Anyways, I'm prowling this website as I'm pretty certain my next (try) notebook will be a thinkpad T60.

pax et bonum,
frzntoz

pundit
Junior Member
Junior Member
Posts: 318
Joined: Tue Feb 28, 2006 9:52 pm
Location: Ann Arbor, USA
Contact:

#169 Post by pundit » Mon May 15, 2006 3:48 pm

zephyr wrote:I write a lot of software the old-fashioned way that I learned in undergrad and grad school: vi open in one terminal and gcc in another. The lack of alt-tab'ing between terminal windows is a major problem with me since I do this incessantly. Bringing up Expose and clicking on one of the windows just isn't going to do it.
frzntoz wrote:Actually, you can cycle through those windows with apple key-tilde key.
This makes life much easier as I write code in the same manner :)
I tried mentioning this but it must have gotten lost in the rest of my post.
cmd-tab cycles through the apps, and cmd-tilde cycles through windows in an app.
There is no necessity to leave the keyboard (Expose) to reach an appropriate window.

Regarding the heat, I have been following up on those discussions as well. But I can definitely see temperature thresholds tweaking to be a much faster solution. Either that or move to a slightly cooler room, which has worked well for me so far.

And regarding building, there is so much one takes for granted as "just as is" on a Linux box that's not present on a Mac OS X box. You're assuming all your build tools are fine and in place. This is not so. You have to first get a working build-tool-set, and then take it from there.

Darwinports is like BSD's ports system or Gentoo's Portage. It consists of a collection of rulesets required to fetch and build Free software.
Happily picks up his three grand; unhappily hands it over to another company.

taphil
Sophomore Member
Posts: 127
Joined: Sat Apr 17, 2004 2:27 am
Location: La Jolla, CA

#170 Post by taphil » Mon May 15, 2006 4:13 pm

I have Paralllels Workstation for OSX on my MBP (2GHz, 2GB RAM).

It runs and feels like a Pentium 4 2.2GHz or AMD Athlon 2100+ (the only two slowish computers I have experience with) with 512MB RAM allocated to it. It's a lot faster than VirtualPC using a dual-core G5 PowerMac, and I'd say very acceptable for virtualization. Setting up Windows and installing software (MS Office, Adobe CS2) from CDs was a breeze and didn't give me any problems.

I'm particularly interested in it because I hate Excel for Mac and want to use the Windows version of Excel. However, for this use Parallels in its current beta version has been a complete failure. The problem is that I cannot easily get files into Windows or out of Windows. Shared folders, in which Windows accesses a network shared folder from OS X, crashes Windows Explorer when I try to access it. USB drives connect for a while before disappearing and causing Windows to freeze. The only way I figure to get a large number of files onto Windows is by CD, and to get files off is by email. Perhaps the software will work at some point, it is beta after all, but still has a long way to go and for now I can't bear to use it.

zephyr
Posts: 48
Joined: Fri May 12, 2006 2:05 am

#171 Post by zephyr » Mon May 15, 2006 4:39 pm

taphil wrote:The problem is that I cannot easily get files into Windows or out of Windows. Shared folders, in which Windows accesses a network shared folder from OS X, crashes Windows Explorer when I try to access it. USB drives connect for a while before disappearing and causing Windows to freeze. The only way I figure to get a large number of files onto Windows is by CD, and to get files off is by email. Perhaps the software will work at some point, it is beta after all, but still has a long way to go and for now I can't bear to use it.
Can't you ftp/scp/ssh between Windows and MacOS?

taphil
Sophomore Member
Posts: 127
Joined: Sat Apr 17, 2004 2:27 am
Location: La Jolla, CA

#172 Post by taphil » Mon May 15, 2006 8:30 pm

I didn't think about that, but I guess I could. But I'm no whiz at setting that stuff up.

zephyr
Posts: 48
Joined: Fri May 12, 2006 2:05 am

#173 Post by zephyr » Tue May 16, 2006 6:49 pm

pundit wrote:
zephyr wrote:I write a lot of software the old-fashioned way that I learned in undergrad and grad school: vi open in one terminal and gcc in another. The lack of alt-tab'ing between terminal windows is a major problem with me since I do this incessantly. Bringing up Expose and clicking on one of the windows just isn't going to do it.
frzntoz wrote:Actually, you can cycle through those windows with apple key-tilde key.
This makes life much easier as I write code in the same manner :)
I tried mentioning this but it must have gotten lost in the rest of my post.
cmd-tab cycles through the apps, and cmd-tilde cycles through windows in an app.
There is no necessity to leave the keyboard (Expose) to reach an appropriate window.
I already knew about command-tilde; this only cycles unidirectionally through terminal shells. When writing code I may have 5 or more files open at once, so I don't want to unidirectionally go through all of them. The alt-tab in Windows and Linux (at least with KDE) is perfect, because it swaps the last two windows in the usage stack.


Regarding the heat, I have been following up on those discussions as well. But I can definitely see temperature thresholds tweaking to be a much faster solution. Either that or move to a slightly cooler room, which has worked well for me so far.
I like to read and watch movies for a long time in bed, so this means AC power is needed. Unfortunately, the MBP I purchased got uncomfortably on AC.

And regarding building, there is so much one takes for granted as "just as is" on a Linux box that's not present on a Mac OS X box. You're assuming all your build tools are fine and in place. This is not so. You have to first get a working build-tool-set, and then take it from there.

Darwinports is like BSD's ports system or Gentoo's Portage. It consists of a collection of rulesets required to fetch and build Free software.

What is there about a build tool set beside a gcc/g++ compiler and make? I assume that's all you'd need. So supposing those are available (and they were when I played around with the dev tools CD), am I correct in assuming that configure/make will work fine if given the proper installation directory?

pundit
Junior Member
Junior Member
Posts: 318
Joined: Tue Feb 28, 2006 9:52 pm
Location: Ann Arbor, USA
Contact:

#174 Post by pundit » Tue May 16, 2006 8:43 pm

zephyr wrote:What is there about a build tool set beside a gcc/g++ compiler and make? I assume that's all you'd need. So supposing those are available (and they were when I played around with the dev tools CD), am I correct in assuming that configure/make will work fine if given the proper installation directory?
It depends. What sorts of things do you frequently (want to) build? If they're relatively mainstream and/or simple things, you ought to be OK.

Everything about the innards (at least the Unix userland) of OS X seem a little old school. Case in point, I had a build die on me over and over today, and upon staring at it, it turns out it was using OS X's ancient 'libtool.' (which doesn't like GNU style long options, like --silent) Luckily, they provide the GNU variant as glibtool somewhere and I symlinked it to be 'libtool' and everythiing went off fine. Sometimes you aren't so lucky, and you need to fetch a 'proper' (and by 'proper' I mean GNU style, and not BSD style) tool to do the job.

And then there's Python and then there's Fortran and there are a lot of things that aren't at their best out of the box. If you're building simple things, you will be fine. If you need to build more bleeding edge stuff, you need to get a working build environment first.

And by "working," I mean "modern."
Happily picks up his three grand; unhappily hands it over to another company.

archer6
Moderator Emeritus
Moderator Emeritus
Posts: 2674
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 10:51 pm
Location: California, USA

#175 Post by archer6 » Tue May 16, 2006 9:05 pm

pundit wrote:And then there's Python and then there's Fortran and there are a lot of things that aren't at their best out of the box. If you're building simple things, you will be fine. If you need to build more bleeding edge stuff, you need to get a working build environment first.

And by "working," I mean "modern."
Well said,

Wow! Fortran that brings back memories. Then there is Python, Mmmm.

Reminds me of my first PowerBook 140 with a whopping 4 megs ram and a 40 MB hard drive! And the "optional" modem!
Favorites From My ThinkPad Collection

Workstations... T40p ~ T41p ~ T42p ~ T43p ~ T60p ~ T61p ~ W500 ~ W510
T Series..... T22 ~ 30 ~ 40 ~ 41 ~ 42 ~ 43 ~ 60 ~ 400 ~ 500 ~ 510
X Series..... X20 ~ 30 ~ 40 ~ 60 ~ 60s ~ 200 ~ 200s ~ 301
Netbooks... S-10 ~ S-12

rocketman
Junior Member
Junior Member
Posts: 359
Joined: Tue Aug 31, 2004 5:16 pm
Location: Florida

#176 Post by rocketman » Tue May 16, 2006 9:50 pm

Just in case anybody cares the 15" MacBook Pro was upgraded today. The 2.0GHz is now the low end and the 2.16GHz the high end (2.0GHz now costs what the 1.83GHz did and the 2.16GHz what the 2GHz did. so in effect a drop of $200.
There is also now a choice of displays, the standard matte version or a shiny reflective "Xbrite" type display at no extra charge.

zephyr
Posts: 48
Joined: Fri May 12, 2006 2:05 am

#177 Post by zephyr » Tue May 16, 2006 11:46 pm

rocketman wrote:Just in case anybody cares the 15" MacBook Pro was upgraded today. The 2.0GHz is now the low end and the 2.16GHz the high end (2.0GHz now costs what the 1.83GHz did and the 2.16GHz what the 2GHz did. so in effect a drop of $200.
There is also now a choice of displays, the standard matte version or a shiny reflective "Xbrite" type display at no extra charge.
That is certainly weighing on my mind. I have a Thinkpad T60p on order that's due to arrive this week. (It has taken nearly 4 weeks since the time I placed the order, but that is a rant for a different day.) During that span I bought a MBP for kicks to try out from Amazon. I was very impressed with it, but due to its overheating, I returned it.

There is just something about that MBP that I can't shake. It's like an old expression I once heard, "I should just buy it now while I'm still young and foolish." I can be an old fart for the rest of my life and keep that Thinkpad, but I can only be young for a few more years of my life. Decisions, decisions...

archer6
Moderator Emeritus
Moderator Emeritus
Posts: 2674
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 10:51 pm
Location: California, USA

#178 Post by archer6 » Wed May 17, 2006 12:55 am

rocketman wrote:Just in case anybody cares the 15" MacBook Pro was upgraded today. The 2.0GHz is now the low end and the 2.16GHz the high end (2.0GHz now costs what the 1.83GHz did and the 2.16GHz what the 2GHz did. so in effect a drop of $200.
There is also now a choice of displays, the standard matte version or a shiny reflective "Xbrite" type display at no extra charge.
Thanks rocketman for the heads up on this.
zephyr wrote:There is just something about that MBP that I can't shake. It's like an old expression I once heard, "I should just buy it now while I'm still young and foolish." I can be an old fart for the rest of my life and keep that Thinkpad, but I can only be young for a few more years of my life. Decisions, decisions...
Aaa Haa, I see...

MBP = young & foolish. ThinkPad = old fart.
So, what does that make me? :D
Thanks for the humor... I think...

Archer6

MBP on order-
Too many ThinkPads-
Favorites From My ThinkPad Collection

Workstations... T40p ~ T41p ~ T42p ~ T43p ~ T60p ~ T61p ~ W500 ~ W510
T Series..... T22 ~ 30 ~ 40 ~ 41 ~ 42 ~ 43 ~ 60 ~ 400 ~ 500 ~ 510
X Series..... X20 ~ 30 ~ 40 ~ 60 ~ 60s ~ 200 ~ 200s ~ 301
Netbooks... S-10 ~ S-12

zephyr
Posts: 48
Joined: Fri May 12, 2006 2:05 am

Pundit's MBP

#179 Post by zephyr » Sun May 21, 2006 3:33 am

Hi Pundit, how do you like your MacCookBook Pro? Has it burned you yet? Have you needed skin grafts yet?

Let me tell you, I went in the exact opposite direction as you. I bought and returned two MBPs and just now got a Thinkpad T60p. The T60p is absolutely amazing. Let me compare it with the MBP:

1. Weight: I have the 6cell battery, and the T60p is just a wee bit heavier than the MBP.

2. Screen: the MBP's screen was a bit brighter. My T60p has one stuck pixel.

3. MBP has Dashboard. I thought that was the slickest thing until I found Konfabulator (aka Yahoo Widgets) for Windows. This is a draw.

4. Like you, I am a photographer. Where is the Intel-compiled Photoshop? Doesn't exist yet. My combination of Photoshop7 and Picassa (for slideshows) cannot be beat.

5. Heat: The MBP's heat was unbearable, and Apple is still screwing around with their own loyal customers by not even acknowledging the problem. My T60p runs much, much, much cooler. Same CPU, same video card (ATI V5200 vs. ATI X1600). This is a huge win for the T60p.

6. I'm a Unix-head, and I love the idea of the MacOS being BSD. However, I've got Linux running inside VMWare. It's pretty close, but MacOS wins here.

7. Looks: The MBP is sleek and sexy, that is for sure. But scientifically speaking, the T60p is more manly.

8. The freaking Alt-Tab combination works as expected on the T60p for my ssh terminal programs.


Anyhow, I think the MBP and T60p are the absolute two best laptops on the market, bar none. Maybe I will re-visit Apple's notebooks next year when Photoshop CS3 is Intel-compiled and Apple fixes the heat problem.

christopher_wolf
Special Member
Posts: 5741
Joined: Sat Oct 08, 2005 1:24 pm
Location: UC Berkeley, California
Contact:

Re: Pundit's MBP

#180 Post by christopher_wolf » Sun May 21, 2006 4:15 am

zephyr wrote:Hi Pundit, how do you like your MacCookBook Pro? Has it burned you yet? Have you needed skin grafts yet?
LOL; you know...Somebody actually did get burnt like that....on their private areas. I think that it was a Dell laptop and the victim was a scientist.

http://www.theregister.co.uk/2002/11/22 ... th_laptop/

also

http://www.theregister.co.uk/2003/01/17 ... med_in_sa/

I can now say, with the utmost powerful proof, that Dells *are* indeed bad for your health. :lol:

Talk about hot laptops.
IBM ThinkPad T43 Model 2668-72U 14.1" SXGA+ 1GB |IBM 701c

~o/
I met someone who looks a lot like you.
She does the things you do.
But she is an IBM.
/~o ---ELO from "Yours Truly 2059"

Post Reply
  • Similar Topics
    Replies
    Views
    Last post

Return to “ThinkPad T60/T61 Series”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 50 guests