T60p cooling system replacement/upgrade
Posted: Tue Apr 29, 2014 5:19 pm
What is the best option when replacing a cooling system in the following ThinkPad?
T60p, widescreen 15,4'' (8743-CTO)
Core 2 Duo T7600 2.33GHz CPU
ATi FireGL 5250
The Hardware Reference Manual for the widescreen T60(p) lists only FRU 41W6409 as suitable for a widescreen T60p with a discrete GPU. In other threads, in these forums and elsewhere, I stubled upon suggestions of FRUs 41V9932 or 41W6407 - these are, however, suitable for a normal (i.e. non-widescreen) T60(p), according to the HRM for that model.
The questions so far:
- are FRUs 41V9932 and 41W6407 compatible with a widescreen T60p as well, or will only FRU 41W6409 work?
- should 41V9932 and 41W6407 be generally (i.e. mechanically) compatible with a widescreen T60p, will the 41V9932 be able to cool the T7600 CPU sufficiently, or would at least a 41W6407 be necessary due to it having a longer CPU heatpipe (extending to both vents)?
Alternatively, would a 3-heatpipe T61p heatsink fit, specifically this one (I think it is FRU 42X4685)? From what I heard it is generally a better solution as, apart from having a double CPU heatpipe, it is designed to make direct contact with the GPU, and has a better-quality fan than the T60(p) cooling systems. The question is whether it will fit mechanically into a widescreen T60p.
Many thanks in advance for a clarification on the above matters, which after reading a share of relevant information remain unclear to me.
T60p, widescreen 15,4'' (8743-CTO)
Core 2 Duo T7600 2.33GHz CPU
ATi FireGL 5250
The Hardware Reference Manual for the widescreen T60(p) lists only FRU 41W6409 as suitable for a widescreen T60p with a discrete GPU. In other threads, in these forums and elsewhere, I stubled upon suggestions of FRUs 41V9932 or 41W6407 - these are, however, suitable for a normal (i.e. non-widescreen) T60(p), according to the HRM for that model.
The questions so far:
- are FRUs 41V9932 and 41W6407 compatible with a widescreen T60p as well, or will only FRU 41W6409 work?
- should 41V9932 and 41W6407 be generally (i.e. mechanically) compatible with a widescreen T60p, will the 41V9932 be able to cool the T7600 CPU sufficiently, or would at least a 41W6407 be necessary due to it having a longer CPU heatpipe (extending to both vents)?
Alternatively, would a 3-heatpipe T61p heatsink fit, specifically this one (I think it is FRU 42X4685)? From what I heard it is generally a better solution as, apart from having a double CPU heatpipe, it is designed to make direct contact with the GPU, and has a better-quality fan than the T60(p) cooling systems. The question is whether it will fit mechanically into a widescreen T60p.
Many thanks in advance for a clarification on the above matters, which after reading a share of relevant information remain unclear to me.