Page 1 of 1

Screen shot - which screen would be better?

Posted: Thu Jun 08, 2006 3:15 pm
by serpico
Out of the clear blue, as I was moving a window across the extended desktop to my laptop screen, I noticed a vertical red line on the screen. It runs the entire height of the screen about 1" from the right edge. There is also a shorter grey horizontal line that runs about 3" from the left edge and sits about 0.5" from the top edge. This is a Samsung screen.

Is my screen shot? I have pics, but no hosting. If someone cares to host, I can upload them.

Anyone know if Lenovo can be convinced to send an interim replacement while they repair/replace my laptop?

Which screen should I ask for?

Posted: Thu Jun 08, 2006 3:59 pm
by serpico
Just got off the phone with Lenovo. I'm sending it in for service; they don't do loaners.

It probably won't help, but I'm going to ask for a specific screen as a replacement. I was going to request a Hydis panel, since the defective screen was a Samsung. Also, my first T60 had a Hydis panel which seemed slightly better than the Samsung (except for the brilliant green stuck pixel in the center). Anyone have a panel preference?

Also, while they've got the laptop, maybe I'll ask them to swap out the Panasonic battery for a Sony. Probably futile, but no harm in asking.

My earlier post comparing the various parts on 14" T60s: here

Re: Screen shot - which screen would be better?

Posted: Thu Jun 08, 2006 6:43 pm
by astro
serpico wrote:Out of the clear blue, as I was moving a window across the extended desktop to my laptop screen, I noticed a vertical red line on the screen. It runs the entire height of the screen about 1" from the right edge. There is also a shorter grey horizontal line that runs about 3" from the left edge and sits about 0.5" from the top edge. This is a Samsung screen.
Are you sure it is not a driver issue? Does it appear on bootup?

So you're saying you've got "dead lines" as opposed to "dead pixels"?

I have found even the latest ATI driver to be good, but still a little buggy and FWIW, my Samsung screen is brilliant and I wouldn't swap it for anything (haven't seen the other makes though).

Re: Screen shot - which screen would be better?

Posted: Thu Jun 08, 2006 6:49 pm
by serpico
astro wrote:Are you sure it is not a driver issue? Does it appear on bootup?

So you're saying you've got "dead lines" as opposed to "dead pixels"?
It's difficult to see at bootup as the screen is black, but if I go into the BIOS, the red line is clearly there.

Yeah, I went from stuck pixels on the first T60 to a stuck line on this T60! If anyone wants to see pics, just PM me and I'll send 'em.

On a positive note, Lenovo service was very professional - they are sending me a box to return the laptop in for warranty service.

Posted: Fri Jun 09, 2006 12:19 pm
by FlexOink
use http://www.imageshack.us/ to host images.

Posted: Fri Jun 09, 2006 10:57 pm
by hoya
I find Hydis makes the best 14.1" SXGA+ panel so definitely go for that. TMD and Samsung are ok, but Hydis is a bit brighter with better contrast and more true whites (rather than pinkish whites).

My Sanyo and Sony batteries seem identical on the T60 - both fit perfectly.

Posted: Sat Jun 10, 2006 7:11 am
by serpico
FlexOink wrote:use http://www.imageshack.us/ to host images.
Thanks for the tip.

I switched the desktop to yellow so the line would show up better in a picture:
Image


Image

Posted: Thu Jul 06, 2006 12:29 pm
by serpico
Lenovo has replaced the screen on my laptop. If I do a parts lookup, it shows "Parts shipped with your system". It shows a Samsung lcd, which is what this laptop originally came with. Is this list updated to reflect any parts replaced under warranty?

Is there any other way to confirm which lcd they have installed?

Posted: Thu Jul 06, 2006 1:49 pm
by hoya
you can try some of these:
http://www.holin.com/cindex.html
http://members.datafast.net.au/~dft0802/downloads.htm
http://www.astra32.com/download.htm

also, AIDA16 should be included on the Ultimate Boot CD.
It was discontinued, so the version has not been updated in awhile.

Go ahead an create a CD and boot it. After the CD boots it should be F4 for the system utilities, then F1 for AIDA16.

AIDA16 loads Page 1 which is CPU diagnostic, then you page down to Page 15 for monitor information. I just tried it at work and it identified my Samsung LCD monitor. Sometimes, if it can't identify the panel it will say unknown, sometimes it won't even display Page 15, other times it gives the information.