Buy T410 i3 with SSD or i5? (Or t510 or Samsung Q430-11)
Posted: Tue Sep 28, 2010 8:11 am
I am looking to get a T410. This notebook will be used mainly for Application Development, web surfing and ocassionally (5% of the time) Picture Editing with Photo Shop. I will also be using vmware to run a virtual Windows XP machine that runs an J2EE application that I will be migrating to .Net. I am currently running this on a 4GB desktop with a Core 2 Duo 7500 with no performance issues.
I dont think I need the discreet graphics. I think the Intel will be fine, considering how little I will use Photo Shop (I have a nice Desktop if needed).
What I am trying to weigh is if I should get an i5 with the 7200 Drive or an i3 with SSD. I can get them for about the same price (actually the i3 with SSD is a little more). There does seems to be quite a bit of difference in performance between the i3 and i5. Later on, I could get install my own SSD, but the chances of that are unlikely and I want to get the BEST fit for me now.
Also, I know I am in a Thinkpad forum but I am still not 100% convinced the Thinkpad is the right machine. To fit within my budget (under $900) I have considered just going to Best Buy and getting a new Samsung Q430-11. In order to get a T410, I pretty much have to go with a remanufactured. I am not opposed to that, since they do come with a warranty. But still, I do have to wonder if I am making a mistake going remanuf. versus new.
Any advice is much appreciated.
(Since posting this, I am really considering the t510 now with the bigger screen. I think I will be sorry if I get smaller than 15"...)
I dont think I need the discreet graphics. I think the Intel will be fine, considering how little I will use Photo Shop (I have a nice Desktop if needed).
What I am trying to weigh is if I should get an i5 with the 7200 Drive or an i3 with SSD. I can get them for about the same price (actually the i3 with SSD is a little more). There does seems to be quite a bit of difference in performance between the i3 and i5. Later on, I could get install my own SSD, but the chances of that are unlikely and I want to get the BEST fit for me now.
Also, I know I am in a Thinkpad forum but I am still not 100% convinced the Thinkpad is the right machine. To fit within my budget (under $900) I have considered just going to Best Buy and getting a new Samsung Q430-11. In order to get a T410, I pretty much have to go with a remanufactured. I am not opposed to that, since they do come with a warranty. But still, I do have to wonder if I am making a mistake going remanuf. versus new.
Any advice is much appreciated.
(Since posting this, I am really considering the t510 now with the bigger screen. I think I will be sorry if I get smaller than 15"...)