Personally, I've tried lots of sw firewalls, and when it comes to the conclusion, thing that bugged me the most is the sw firewall itself. Taking closer look to each alert, I rarely have to "deny" anything.
I dropped them and no problem since. Really all the "outbound connection monitor, beware, bla bla bla..." I heard enough. If we'd like to talk about surfing habit, well I did come across bad sites, ads, cracks, hacks, ... whatever, and Firefox with noscript and adblock plus does do way *perfect job.
I was afraid of using my pc without a sw fw, really. It took myself a bit guts and a while just to confidently toss them all and use that Windows FW, but so far so good. I can even disable that Windows FW but... well, leave it for MS/Windows to be happy
btw I never store any surfing pass in the web browsers, including emails, banks, etc. Status bar does come handy to check for phishing, I usually hover the link and look at the status bar before I clicked on it. I reported bunch of Paypal and banks phishing to FF that way
And at least make sure keeping Windows up-to-date all the time.
In the end, it's all come down to the actual needs.
dsigma6 wrote:With XP I use Comodo firewall, AVG anti-virus, as well as the utterly useless Spybot and Ad-Aware. They have found NOTHING but things like "Windows firewall disabled" and "Security notifications disabled." It's like thanks, I know they're disabled, since I did it.
I use AdWatch and uncheck/disable Spybot TeaTimer, then config them to be *silent*
