760XD trouble & awful Mwave sound (HOW-TO:replace Mwave)
Posted: Wed Nov 22, 2006 7:26 pm
I own an IBM Thinkpad 760EL laptop and recently bought a used 760XD on eBay, which spects sound really nice on paper (higher screen resolution, slightly faster CPU, TV-out, joystick/ midi jack, MPEG2 decoder chip), but there are sever flaws those make of the 760XD a real cucumber.
I use my laptop mainly on travels for writing and for playing antique emulated and DOS games. My German model Thinkpad 760XD also has no telephony jack installed, thus I can not use the (infamously slow) Mwave modem anyway. (I also had to install the harddisk from my 760EL since my 760XD specimen lacked it.)
awful Mwave sound:
The Mwave sound/modem DSP sounds horrible and in DOS mode it only works when I launch Windows 98SE (takes quite a while to boot) and exit from there back to DOS. Booting directly into plain DOS mode of Windows 98SE crashes MWave and makes no sound. Also FASTCFG shows nonsense instead of the Soundblaster adress,IRQ and DMA in this state. Apparently the DSP loads its SoundBlaster emulator firmware only when starting windows, and thus can not be used at all from plain DOS.
I first tried to install the Mwave driver (v2.25) in a different directory ("C:\Programme\Thinkpad\MWave\"), but apparently the DOS mode driver can not handle longer paths since MWAVE.BAT always crashed when I tried to start MWave in DOS mode even after quitting Win98SE. (It took 2 days to find out why.)
The sound quality during Windows 98SE is a bad joke; DOS games have a lot of static, and MIDI files sound horrible; the pitch of some voices is very off, pitchbend and vibrato is apparently ignored completely and in some songs a triangle(?) is hammering 10 times as loud as the rest. Other GM instrument timbres seem to be made from plain sine wave with attack/decay envelope and thus sound way too quiet in the bass range. Initially drums were completely lacking. During installation the driver complained about a missing sample set.
Because the samples are not available on the IBM site anymore, I installed a 3 diskette MWave sample set (v1.00) from a different MWave card, which at least added a few halfway realistic drums and orchestra hit sounds, but the rest sounds still like plain sine wave and pitches match even worse than before. (I first tried to install that entire sound card driver (v2.33), which caused another crash.)
Also the FM sound emulation is a bad joke. I am collector of music keyboards (see http://www.informatik.fh-hamburg.de/~wi ... index.html) and hear immediately the difference. Although some timbres are nice, the envelopes behave not at all like on a real SoundBlaster OPL3. (I own a "SoundBlaster AWE64 Gold" for comparison, which was the best sounding ISA sound card.) Like with midi files some vibratos and pitchbends are completely missing, and timbres are very off. Dull drums turn into a bright click or hiss, some envelopes end too fast and other timbres are way too bright (e.g. a harsh "dwellnng" instead of "woowoowoowoonnng"). As a composer I consider this quirky Mwave synth hardly usable for making music; a real SoundBlaster is much better. Perhaps genuinely some space aliens have created the Mwave chip for their own secret sinister purposes rather than what it was advertised for. ;-]
I read that Mwave could also emulate a "SoundBlaster Pro"; does anybody know how this works? (But I guess that not the emulates card but the quality of the emulator is the problem.)
The joystick jack needs a special plug that is hard to replicate by my own. I read that the video in/out plugs can be made from a sawed-off transistor. I wish I could reuse the ESS soundcard from my 760EL for the XD, however its joystick/midi jack section is unfortunately empty (traces exist, but a chip and small parts are not soldered in). Does anybody know which components could be soldered here to make that jack work? I start to hate Mwave the more I work with it.
I downloaded a Thinkpad service manual, that lists which parts are interchangable among 760 series models; the sound card unfortunately is claimed to be not interchangable. (Why? Is it perhaps only a mechanical problem?)
black screen borders:
The LCD of the 760XD has 1024*768 pixels (including about 6 bad ones) while my 760EL had only 800*600 (with an entire row of pixels too bright), but while the EL could stretch all standard resolutions to full screen, the XD makes an ugly black border around the screen in 640*480 and 800*600 resolution. The DOS text mode has a black 2cm border at top and bottom, which on my blue screen background looks like BASIC on an Atari 800XL. Thus the usable screen area is in many games smaller than with the old 760EL.
noisy fan & smouldering smell:
While the 760EL needs no coolers and thus was almost silent, the 760XD contains a small fan on the graphics card, which after about an hour starts to hiss. (Mine doesn't start always, likely because its noisy bearing is damaged.) I don't think that my 760 laptops run really hot (my 760EL consumed only 18W without drive access), however both laptops always odour somehow pungent of ozone (?, likely the LCD backlight transformer) and also a bit burned like when something inside is slowly smouldering. I hope the stinkpad won't suddenly explode or burst into flames - at least my Li-Ion battery pack (from the 760EL) is not a Sony flare shell. The original 760XD battery pack is completely dead and is completely ignored when inserted (i.e. no battery icon is displayed). The standby NiCad battery (3 welded button cells) under the keyboard cover of my 760XD also show some white battey leak residues on their shrink sleeve. I hope it won't blow up. (I saw this when I disconnected the CMOS battery to reset the unknown BIOS password of the previous owner. Plugging the internal speaker into the white "password clear" jumper hole next to the CD-ROM bay did the trick.)
DRIVER NEEDED:
Does anybody know where I can download the original MWave midi sample set and MPEG hardware codec driver for the Thinkpad 760XD under Windows 98SE?
sound card joystick upgrade?
I read that the ESS sound card from my 760EL can be installed in the XD to get rid of the infamous Mwave sound system. But so far I know, the joystick/MIDI port is also part of the sound card and my 760EL lacks it. I once took the 760EL apart and so far I remember, there were indeed empty traces for installing that port on the sound card, but an IC and some discrete SMD components were omitted.
Can the ESS sound card be upgraded with the joystick/midi port (possibly transplanted from the Mwave card)?
I use my laptop mainly on travels for writing and for playing antique emulated and DOS games. My German model Thinkpad 760XD also has no telephony jack installed, thus I can not use the (infamously slow) Mwave modem anyway. (I also had to install the harddisk from my 760EL since my 760XD specimen lacked it.)
awful Mwave sound:
The Mwave sound/modem DSP sounds horrible and in DOS mode it only works when I launch Windows 98SE (takes quite a while to boot) and exit from there back to DOS. Booting directly into plain DOS mode of Windows 98SE crashes MWave and makes no sound. Also FASTCFG shows nonsense instead of the Soundblaster adress,IRQ and DMA in this state. Apparently the DSP loads its SoundBlaster emulator firmware only when starting windows, and thus can not be used at all from plain DOS.
I first tried to install the Mwave driver (v2.25) in a different directory ("C:\Programme\Thinkpad\MWave\"), but apparently the DOS mode driver can not handle longer paths since MWAVE.BAT always crashed when I tried to start MWave in DOS mode even after quitting Win98SE. (It took 2 days to find out why.)
The sound quality during Windows 98SE is a bad joke; DOS games have a lot of static, and MIDI files sound horrible; the pitch of some voices is very off, pitchbend and vibrato is apparently ignored completely and in some songs a triangle(?) is hammering 10 times as loud as the rest. Other GM instrument timbres seem to be made from plain sine wave with attack/decay envelope and thus sound way too quiet in the bass range. Initially drums were completely lacking. During installation the driver complained about a missing sample set.
Because the samples are not available on the IBM site anymore, I installed a 3 diskette MWave sample set (v1.00) from a different MWave card, which at least added a few halfway realistic drums and orchestra hit sounds, but the rest sounds still like plain sine wave and pitches match even worse than before. (I first tried to install that entire sound card driver (v2.33), which caused another crash.)
Also the FM sound emulation is a bad joke. I am collector of music keyboards (see http://www.informatik.fh-hamburg.de/~wi ... index.html) and hear immediately the difference. Although some timbres are nice, the envelopes behave not at all like on a real SoundBlaster OPL3. (I own a "SoundBlaster AWE64 Gold" for comparison, which was the best sounding ISA sound card.) Like with midi files some vibratos and pitchbends are completely missing, and timbres are very off. Dull drums turn into a bright click or hiss, some envelopes end too fast and other timbres are way too bright (e.g. a harsh "dwellnng" instead of "woowoowoowoonnng"). As a composer I consider this quirky Mwave synth hardly usable for making music; a real SoundBlaster is much better. Perhaps genuinely some space aliens have created the Mwave chip for their own secret sinister purposes rather than what it was advertised for. ;-]
I read that Mwave could also emulate a "SoundBlaster Pro"; does anybody know how this works? (But I guess that not the emulates card but the quality of the emulator is the problem.)
The joystick jack needs a special plug that is hard to replicate by my own. I read that the video in/out plugs can be made from a sawed-off transistor. I wish I could reuse the ESS soundcard from my 760EL for the XD, however its joystick/midi jack section is unfortunately empty (traces exist, but a chip and small parts are not soldered in). Does anybody know which components could be soldered here to make that jack work? I start to hate Mwave the more I work with it.
I downloaded a Thinkpad service manual, that lists which parts are interchangable among 760 series models; the sound card unfortunately is claimed to be not interchangable. (Why? Is it perhaps only a mechanical problem?)
black screen borders:
The LCD of the 760XD has 1024*768 pixels (including about 6 bad ones) while my 760EL had only 800*600 (with an entire row of pixels too bright), but while the EL could stretch all standard resolutions to full screen, the XD makes an ugly black border around the screen in 640*480 and 800*600 resolution. The DOS text mode has a black 2cm border at top and bottom, which on my blue screen background looks like BASIC on an Atari 800XL. Thus the usable screen area is in many games smaller than with the old 760EL.
noisy fan & smouldering smell:
While the 760EL needs no coolers and thus was almost silent, the 760XD contains a small fan on the graphics card, which after about an hour starts to hiss. (Mine doesn't start always, likely because its noisy bearing is damaged.) I don't think that my 760 laptops run really hot (my 760EL consumed only 18W without drive access), however both laptops always odour somehow pungent of ozone (?, likely the LCD backlight transformer) and also a bit burned like when something inside is slowly smouldering. I hope the stinkpad won't suddenly explode or burst into flames - at least my Li-Ion battery pack (from the 760EL) is not a Sony flare shell. The original 760XD battery pack is completely dead and is completely ignored when inserted (i.e. no battery icon is displayed). The standby NiCad battery (3 welded button cells) under the keyboard cover of my 760XD also show some white battey leak residues on their shrink sleeve. I hope it won't blow up. (I saw this when I disconnected the CMOS battery to reset the unknown BIOS password of the previous owner. Plugging the internal speaker into the white "password clear" jumper hole next to the CD-ROM bay did the trick.)
DRIVER NEEDED:
Does anybody know where I can download the original MWave midi sample set and MPEG hardware codec driver for the Thinkpad 760XD under Windows 98SE?
sound card joystick upgrade?
I read that the ESS sound card from my 760EL can be installed in the XD to get rid of the infamous Mwave sound system. But so far I know, the joystick/MIDI port is also part of the sound card and my 760EL lacks it. I once took the 760EL apart and so far I remember, there were indeed empty traces for installing that port on the sound card, but an IC and some discrete SMD components were omitted.
Can the ESS sound card be upgraded with the joystick/midi port (possibly transplanted from the Mwave card)?