Thinkpads Forum

I would like your opinions on this model.
I'm thinking on getting the A6-4400M and the HD 7670M as upgrades.

Thanks

I've had mine about two months (A4300M) and I liked the machine overall BUT...it crashed last week, refused to reboot and after many attempts with recovery disks, tech support now says that it sounds like a system board problem and I'll have to send it in for repair. So I'm conflicted...it has a great keyboard and a nice display but I'm pretty turned off that I have this problem already. It's my first Thinkpad and it might very well be my last.

Best of luck to you...

BlueEdge wrote:I've had mine about two months (A4300M) and I liked the machine overall BUT...it crashed last week, refused to reboot and after many attempts with recovery disks, tech support now says that it sounds like a system board problem and I'll have to send it in for repair. So I'm conflicted...it has a great keyboard and a nice display but I'm pretty turned off that I have this problem already. It's my first Thinkpad and it might very well be my last.

Best of luck to you...

I still have not decided yet but my A31 (2001) and my X41 (2004-2005?) are still working perfectly!

FWIW, before I bought my Edge I had looked for opinions in these forums, and some experienced Thinkpad owners commented that the Edge series isn't of the same overall quality as the other Thinkpad systems -- the T and W series, in particular. Someone commented that the Edge has more in common with the mass market competition (including Ideapad) than with the traditional Thinkpads. I don't know if that's true, but now that I'm having these problems I'm wondering if maybe they were right.

BlueEdge wrote:FWIW, before I bought my Edge I had looked for opinions in these forums, and some experienced Thinkpad owners commented that the Edge series isn't of the same overall quality as the other Thinkpad systems -- the T and W series, in particular. Someone commented that the Edge has more in common with the mass market competition (including Ideapad) than with the traditional Thinkpads. I don't know if that's true, but now that I'm having these problems I'm wondering if maybe they were right.

They were definitely right. The Thinkpad Edge series is nothing more than an Ideapad with a trackpoint, different finish, and some Thinkvantage software installed. The real Thinkpads (T, W, X series) are constructed much better, with higher quality components and materials. Because of some very attractive deals from the Lenovo outlet in the past year, I purchased a number of Thinkpad Edge E530 laptops, as well as a few Ideapad G585's. Even with very little use, some of the E530's already have failing Ethernet ports (three out of 16 purchased) and the G585's were just a bad purchasing decision on my part-even thought they were only around $150 each. They are terribly slow with the AMD E300 APU, and the best use for them has been robbing them of memory and hard drives for upgrading other systems.

Edge is ThinkPad in the name only...and that applies to every single one of them.

We get a lot of these DOA when purchasing for our clients (bad LCD, bad keyboards, etc). There's a reason why you can get the new thinkpads for as low as $500.

I'd either get an older series ThinkPad or a Toshiba. Although the little LED on the i in ThinkPad is neat (hardly a reason to purchase a laptop though).

I think you'll need to re-evaluate your assertion, "The thinkpad edge is just an ideapad with a trackpoint and ultranav !!!" It seems that - now that IBM has forsook the ultranav on all laptops EXCEPT for the Edge E545, "The thinkpad is just an upgraded edge laptop without the trackpoint!" today ...

Back when I was in high school, all the laptops were thinkpad E520 edges. In my senior year, I worked for the IT department and I remember having problems with many of the laptops, such as bad batteries, freezing issues, and some with white spots on displays. However, they were pretty abused by the students, especially the freshman. One thing that also annoys me about the Edge, is that the palmrests wear out very fast and look terrible after a year.

systemBuilder wrote: It seems that - now that IBM has forsook the ultranav on all laptops EXCEPT for the Edge E545

Seriously buddy what are you talking about? What does IBM have to do with Thinkpads anymore? You ever heard of Lenovo?