beeblebrox wrote:
If I think about innovation, I just need to look at this loaner MacBook Pro that I am typing on (TP is broken again... bad USB ports, as usual)
Magnetic power plug, SD card reader, nice built-in camera for video conferencing, interesting slot-in drive and this magnificent screen (!!). All in a super-slim attractive package. I start to sound like in those Mac commercials.
If only I had the Thinkpad keyboard on it... I would seriously think to switch...
I switched from Thinkpads to a Macbook Pro some seven months ago, and just recently sold it and bought a new T60.
The Macbook Pro does have some nice innovations. I liked the MagSafe connector and backlit keyboard. I didn't find the slot drive very good. It's nice not having to push out a tray, but the slot drive sounds like it's breaking every time it loads or ejects a CD. The camera? Well, that was fun for the first ten minutes I used it - of course different people have different needs, I just didnt need it. It's a very good sales gimmick, though. The screen was brigter than the 14,1" screen on my previous T41p, T43 and present T60 - but it's also very grainy. The coating (mine was matte) was very poor, and this is a common issue with alot of the 15,4" MBP's. Backlit keyboard was great in dim light conditions, but the keyboard itself is awful, just awful.
The slim design of the MBP is also nice. However, the aluminium case is built like an exoskeleton, in which the components are mounted. The small space makes for poor absorbsion of forces. So whatever you do to the exterior, goes right into the components. An Apple technicion actually told me this was a problem.
My MBP (over six months) went in for a new motherboard, slot-drive, keyboard, DC I/O module. I hated it at the end, and ended up going back.
But yes, the magnetic connector and backlit keyboard would be nice on a Thinkpad. The Thinklight isn't too bad though.
I didn't know the MBP had an SD-card reader? Mine didn't.